Ehon is a GOOD app. You will enjoy using it if you have as large of a comic collection as I do. The default "bookshelf" layout is exactly what I imagined. However there are a lot of minor problems, and a couple big ones with Ehon that keep it from delivering a GREAT experience to its users.
Before discussing the flaws with the current version of Ehon (1.0.1), lets start with the positives. I love the "bookshelf" display for your comics. An elegant design is a nessecity for a great app in my opinion. The vast amount of user definable metadata is great. I like the tags feature as well. And though I havent been able to test it, the library sharing is a neat touch!
After using the app for a few days now, I have noticed a few areas with room for improvement. The UI is good, but it could be better. Why can I not slide the selected comic sidebar out of sight for more bookshelf space? Why does the app have new folder/smart folder, import, read, share, and tags buttons at both the top AND bottom of the screen? I also noticed when reading a book in fullscreen mode, which isnt Mt. Lion friendly yet, that the scroll bar never fades away. Very distracting. The full screen control panel could be more responsive too. It feels a little slow. Also, more control via the preferences window is welcomed.
All of the problems I have mentioned so far are to some degree nit picky, but Ehon has two more flaws that will annoy anyone attempting to use it as it is designed. Lots. The first being that the "reveal in finder" function does not work. What a basic function to be missing. The second, and by far the largest fault the app suffers is file management. Importing isnt hard, but getting your files to import CORRECTLY proved a challenge. Why does the "automatic issue number" feature not work if the folder name itself contains numbers? Thats buggy. Why do you not get a confirmation request window of some kind when deleting files, and why are files only deleted from your library and NOT your HD? This forces me to dig through chaotic directories to find the unneeded files. What a pain! For that matter, why are those directories not named after each comic series? I wish Ehon handled your comics more similar to how iTunes does your music.
Ehon is a good app with some room to grow, but considering I paid nothing for it I think Im getting a lot of use out of it as is.
P.S. Please get rid of that ugly "Sorry were empty" sign.